Apfelpatient
  • Home
  • News
  • Rumors
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Reviews
  • Insights
No result
View All Results
  • iPhone 18
  • iPhone 18 Pro
  • iPhone Duo
  • Apple Home
  • Siri AI
  • HomePod
  • HomePod mini
  • HomePod mini 2
  • MacBook Pro
  • Apple TV 4K
  • Apple Watch Series 12
  • Apple Watch Ultra 4
  • AirPods 5
  • iOS 27
  • iPadOS 27
  • macOS
  • MacBook Neo
  • iPhone 17e
  • AirTags
  • iOS 26
  • iPhone 17
  • iPadOS
  • iMac
  • Mac mini
  • Apple TV
  • iPad Pro
  • iPhone Air
  • Apple Vision Pro
  • iPhone 16
  • AirPods 4
  • Apple Watch Ultra
  • MacBook Air
  • iPad
  • AirPods Max
  • AirPods Pro 3
  • Mac Studio
  • Studio Display
  • iPad Air
  • iPad mini
  • watchOS 27
  • Apple CarPlay
  • Apple Pay
  • watchOS 26
  • Home
  • News
  • Rumors
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Reviews
  • Insights
No result
View All Results
Apfelpatient
No result
View All Results
  • iPhone 18
  • iPhone 18 Pro
  • iPhone Duo
  • Apple Home
  • Siri AI
  • HomePod
  • HomePod mini
  • HomePod mini 2
  • MacBook Pro
  • Apple TV 4K
  • Apple Watch Series 12
  • Apple Watch Ultra 4
  • AirPods 5
  • iOS 27
  • iPadOS 27
  • macOS
  • MacBook Neo
  • iPhone 17e
  • AirTags
  • iOS 26
  • iPhone 17
  • iPadOS
  • iMac
  • Mac mini
  • Apple TV
  • iPad Pro
  • iPhone Air
  • Apple Vision Pro
  • iPhone 16
  • AirPods 4
  • Apple Watch Ultra
  • MacBook Air
  • iPad
  • AirPods Max
  • AirPods Pro 3
  • Mac Studio
  • Studio Display
  • iPad Air
  • iPad mini
  • watchOS 27
  • Apple CarPlay
  • Apple Pay
  • watchOS 26

Apple rejects OpenAI's dismissal request

Milan Jovicic by Milan Jovicic
August 20, 2026 - 13:05 CEST
in Apple News
0
Glass facade of Apple Park in Cupertino, backdrop to the Apple OpenAI lawsuit

Image: Apple

WhatsAppFacebookEmail
Threads

This article may contain affiliate links. Learn more on our Partner Program page.

Make Apfelpatient a preferred source One click – and you'll see us more often on Google

Two weeks after filing the dismissal request, Apple has submitted its response. The company maintains its allegations of confidentiality in full and accuses the opposing side of missing the point. The dispute centers on a procedural issue that is often overlooked in media coverage.

Since July, a lawsuit has been underway in a federal court in Northern California, in which Apple accuses two former employees, as well as OpenAI and the hardware company io Products, of stealing trade secrets. In early August, the opposing side filed a motion to dismiss the case, questioning, among other things, Apple's own security measures. Apple has now responded, requesting that the motion be dismissed entirely.

Key Takeaways

  • Apple maintains all allegations and requests that the dismissal request be rejected in its entirety.
  • The company accuses the opposing side of using legal arguments and external evidence that are irrelevant at this stage of the proceedings.
  • Regarding the chat history published by OpenAI, Apple states that it concerns a different process than the one described in the lawsuit.
  • The core allegation is that a former employee accessed a file storage system via a login error.
  • Nothing is decided yet: In this step, a court only checks whether the claim has been presented coherently.

What is being disputed in this procedural step

The crucial point is procedural in nature, and Apple itself makes it its main argument. In a motion to dismiss, the court does not examine whether the allegations are true. It solely examines whether the complaint presents enough facts to make the claim even plausible. All information is assumed in favor of the plaintiff.

This is precisely the point Apple's response addresses: The opposing side repeatedly relies on legal arguments and evidence from outside the complaint, offers improbable, innocuous explanations, and demands that the court draw conclusions in its favor. This is not how a dismissal motion works. As long as enough facts have been presented to support a plausible claim, any substantive disagreement about the allegations is irrelevant at this stage.

What the court will decide soon is not a statement about who is right. It is a statement about whether the proceedings will proceed to the taking of evidence.

According to Apple, the published chat history concerns something else

A separate section of the response addresses a heavily redacted transcript of a conversation that OpenAI had published on its website. In it, a colleague still employed at Apple asks former employee Chang Liu for information about projects. OpenAI interpreted this as evidence that Apple's account of unauthorized access is misleading – after all, Apple employees themselves had requested assistance.

Apple counters that the lawsuit alleges something different. The accusation is not that Liu answered questions, but that after leaving the company, he exploited a login error to access a file storage system containing confidential documents and subsequently downloaded files over a period of weeks. A supervisor's question regarding the handover of documents does not constitute permission for such access. The published document, therefore, provides at best a harmless explanation for behavior that is not even the subject of the lawsuit.

This presentation builds on what OpenAI had presented at the beginning of August with emails and chat histories.

Dispute over components in job interviews

A second issue concerns former Apple Vice President Tang Tan. OpenAI argued that Tan had merely asked applicants to bring readily available parts to a demonstration session. Apple denies this: An individual then employed by Apple was asked to bring components from their own confidential work, specifically batteries, motherboards, and shielding.

The response offers a temporal argument: Just a few hours before an interview, an applicant had downloaded files related to a highly confidential project and taken screenshots – precisely the project that Tan then discussed during the interview. For products available to the public, the argument goes, no one needs a demonstration.

Both sides have so far only made assertions. Neither has been proven; that is the task of the taking of evidence, which will only take place if the lawsuit survives this stage.

How the process has developed so far

The dispute has been ongoing for about six weeks and has changed direction several times during this period.

DateProcedure step
July 11Apple files lawsuit against two former employees, OpenAI and io Products
July 14The opposing side states that there is no evidence to support the accusation.
July 17Apple expands evidence collection to dozens of employees
August 4thOpenAI presents emails and chat histories
August 6Application for dismissal of the action
August 19Apple's response, request for complete dismissal

It remains striking who Apple is not holding accountable in the proceedings. Jony Ive, who co-founded io Products and is responsible for the hardware, does not appear as a defendant – the reasons for this lie in the contractual terms, not in the substance of the case. The extent of Apple's evidence gathering is demonstrated by its access to documents belonging to dozens of OpenAI employees.

Why Apple is even engaged in this dispute

The economic core of the case is not damages. Apple has lost two former executives to a company developing a device intended to compete with the iPhone for the same role. A lawsuit for breach of trade secrets delays this development, ties up resources, and sends a signal to all other employees who receive similar offers. The lawsuit is part of the struggle over the next generation of devices, not merely a legal footnote.

At the same time, the chosen structure is risky. Anyone seeking to protect supplier relationships and component knowledge as trade secrets must demonstrate what aspects of them are not already common industry knowledge – and that is precisely where the opposing side has focused its efforts. Our expectation: The court will uphold some of the claims and reject others. A complete dismissal would be surprising given this level of detail.

Do you think it's right for a corporation to take action against poached employees to hinder a competing product – or is that the legitimate protection of years of development work? Feel free to disagree in the comments.

  • Wearables: One trillion dollars in sales by 2032
  • Bad Monkey: Season 2 starts on December 2nd
  • Apple Smart Home Hub: Code shows the user interface
Was this article helpful?
YesNo
Tags: OpenAITechPatient
SendShareSend
Share

Our Amazon Storefront

A handpicked selection of products for iPhone, Mac and more – sorted by topic and updated regularly.

Shop Now

This post contains affiliate links (including Amazon). We earn a small commission on qualifying purchases – at no extra cost to you. Learn more on our Partner Program page.

Previous Post

AirPods with cameras: Market launch remains at 2027

Next Post

Stick: Season 2 starts on November 4th.

Milan Jovicic

Milan Jovicic

Milan founded Apfelpatient in 2016 and has been responsible for all editorial content since 2018 – news, rumors, how-to guides and product reviews. Here, Apple devices aren't review units kept for two weeks, they're everyday tools: from iPhone to MacBook Pro, MacBook Air and iMac all the way to Apple Vision Pro, at least one device from every product category is in daily use, many of them replaced every year. Every menu path in a guide is checked on the device before it goes live.

Related posts

Presumed Innocent: Season 2 Arrives on February 19

by Milan Jovicic
November 20, 2026 - 17:39 CET
Presumed Innocent season 2: Rachel Brosnahan as defense attorney Lelia Reynolds in the courtroom

Presumed Innocent season 2 premieres February 19 on Apple TV, with Rachel Brosnahan and Matthew Rhys as a married couple in a murder trial.

Read moreDetails

Apple is working on an AI agent for apps, browsers, and code

by Milan Jovicic
November 20, 2026 - 01:18 CET
Apple AI agent: Siri AI icon with a shimmering sphere on a white tile against a dark gray gradient

Apple is working on an AI agent that will work with apps, browsers, and code. This is revealed in a job posting that also mentions on-device models.

Read moreDetails

Apple vs. Epic: Apple says Epic's search terms are too broad

by Milan Jovicic
November 19, 2026 - 10:13 PM CET
Apple vs. Epic: illustrated file folder showing case number 4:20-cv-05640 of the commission proceedings on a dark blue background

Apple vs. Epic: Apple says Epic's search terms are too broad and offers a sample to the court instead of all 122,000 documents.

Read moreDetails

Amazon Black Friday Week: The deals for Apple users

by Milan Jovicic
November 19, 2026 - 17:16 CET
Amazon Black Friday week: iPhone Duo showing the words Black Friday Deals on its display

Amazon Black Friday Week until November 30th: The offers for Apple users and which of these prices are genuine Black Friday deals.

Read moreDetails

iCloud backdoor: Court confirms British order

by Milan Jovicic
November 19, 2026 - 3:59 PM CET
iCloud backdoor: Unfolded iPhone Duo in a folio case showing the Advanced Data Protection settings page with the feature turned on

A British court overturns the secrecy: The order to Apple exists, the lawsuit against the iCloud backdoor becomes public.

Read moreDetails
Load More

Categories

  • Apple Insights
  • Apple Rumors
  • Apple News
  • Apple Tips & Tricks
  • iPhone news, rumors and tips
  • Mac and MacBook News
  • Reviews
Make Apfelpatient a preferred source One click – and you'll see us more often on Google

About APFELPATIENT

APFELPATIENT brings you the latest Apple news, product updates, guides, reviews and tips across the entire Apple ecosystem — from the iPhone to the Mac to the Apple Vision Pro. From the first rumors to confirmed news: researched responsibly.

Follow Apfelpatient

Facebook Instagram YouTube Threads Threads

Company

  • About Apfelpatient
  • Contact
  • Author Profiles

Community

  • Netiquette
  • Push notifications
  • RSS feed

Legal

  • Legal Notice
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie settings
  • Affiliate Program

Resources

  • Sitemap

© 2026 Apfelpatient. All rights reserved.

No result
View All Results
  • Home
  • News
  • Rumors
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Reviews
  • Insights

© 2026 Apfelpatient. All rights reserved. Site map

Change language to Deutsch