Apfelpatient
  • Home
  • News
  • Rumors
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Reviews
  • Insights
No result
View All Results
  • iPhone 18
  • iPhone 18 Pro
  • iPhone Duo
  • Apple Home
  • Siri AI
  • HomePod
  • HomePod mini
  • HomePod mini 2
  • MacBook Pro
  • Apple TV 4K
  • Apple Watch Series 12
  • Apple Watch Ultra 4
  • AirPods 5
  • iOS 27
  • iPadOS 27
  • macOS
  • MacBook Neo
  • iPhone 17e
  • AirTags
  • iOS 26
  • iPhone 17
  • iPadOS
  • iMac
  • Mac mini
  • Apple TV
  • iPad Pro
  • iPhone Air
  • Apple Vision Pro
  • iPhone 16
  • AirPods 4
  • Apple Watch Ultra
  • MacBook Air
  • iPad
  • AirPods Max
  • AirPods Pro 3
  • Mac Studio
  • Studio Display
  • iPad Air
  • iPad mini
  • watchOS 27
  • Apple CarPlay
  • Apple Pay
  • watchOS 26
  • Home
  • News
  • Rumors
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Reviews
  • Insights
No result
View All Results
Apfelpatient
No result
View All Results
  • iPhone 18
  • iPhone 18 Pro
  • iPhone Duo
  • Apple Home
  • Siri AI
  • HomePod
  • HomePod mini
  • HomePod mini 2
  • MacBook Pro
  • Apple TV 4K
  • Apple Watch Series 12
  • Apple Watch Ultra 4
  • AirPods 5
  • iOS 27
  • iPadOS 27
  • macOS
  • MacBook Neo
  • iPhone 17e
  • AirTags
  • iOS 26
  • iPhone 17
  • iPadOS
  • iMac
  • Mac mini
  • Apple TV
  • iPad Pro
  • iPhone Air
  • Apple Vision Pro
  • iPhone 16
  • AirPods 4
  • Apple Watch Ultra
  • MacBook Air
  • iPad
  • AirPods Max
  • AirPods Pro 3
  • Mac Studio
  • Studio Display
  • iPad Air
  • iPad mini
  • watchOS 27
  • Apple CarPlay
  • Apple Pay
  • watchOS 26

Apple vs. OpenAI: Apple counters objections to expert opinions

Milan Jovicic by Milan Jovicic
October 6, 2026 - 05:00 CEST
in Apple News
0
Symbolic image for the Apple OpenAI lawsuit: illustrated file folder showing the case number on a dark blue background

Image: Apfelpatient

WhatsAppFacebookEmail
Threads

This article may contain affiliate links. Learn more on our Partner Program page.

Make Apfelpatient a preferred source One click – and you'll see us more often on Google

Nine days before the preliminary injunction hearing, Apple has turned the tables. OpenAI and the other defendants had sought to have Apple's new expert opinions removed from the proceedings – now Apple is accusing them of violating the court's rules. At the heart of the matter is the statement that former Apple engineer Chang Liu attached to the objections.

In July, Apple sued former employees Chang Liu and Tang Tan, as well as OpenAI and io Products, for theft of trade secrets. Shortly before the hearing for the requested preliminary injunction, Apple submitted five additional expert opinions, whereupon the defendants requested that parts of them be disregarded.

Apple responded with a four-page brief dated October 5, document 173 in case 5:26-cv-07078 in the District Court for the Northern District of California. This is the latest development in a legal battle that has dominated the dispute between Apple and OpenAI since the summer.

Key Takeaways

  • Apple accuses the defendants of using their objections to Apple's new evidence to support additional arguments on the case.
  • The core of the accusation is Chang Liu's statement, which contains eight paragraphs of new statements, including one about his deleted iMac.
  • Together, the objections and explanation comprise nine pages; court rules allow five.
  • Apple demands that the court not strike anything down and decide based on all documents from both sides.
  • The hearing will take place on October 14th at 6 pm German time.

What the court rule allows

The relevant local procedural rule is Rule 7-3(d)(1) of the District Court. It allows a party to raise objections to new evidence submitted by the opposing party only in its reply. Further arguments relating to the original motion are expressly not permitted in such a pleading, and it may not exceed five pages.

Apple believes these boundaries have been crossed. The defendants, for example, disputed whether one of Apple's experts had a sufficient basis for his analysis and adequately considered counter-evidence. These are objections to the content, not to new evidence – and thus a reopening of the debate surrounding Apple's injunction application.

Liu's new explanation

Apple considers Chang Liu's statement, which the defendants attached to their objections, to be the most serious violation. It comprises eight paragraphs of new statements. In it, Liu explains why he deleted all data on his iMac before returning it to Apple – resetting it was standard procedure at Apple so that the device could be passed on to the next employee.

Furthermore, the case concerns the significance of text messages with an Apple supplier and its use of a confidential Apple file. Apple considers this a new argument on the matter, which has no place in a written objection. The objections and explanation together comprise nine pages.

Everything on the table instead of cuts

The pleading does not end with a request to strike Liu's statement. Apple describes the defendants' submission as a kind of further response for which they had not sought permission. Because the defendants have already responded comprehensively to Apple's new evidence, the court should not strike any of Apple's evidence.

Instead, Judge Edward J. Davila is to decide on the preliminary injunction based on the complete file. This expressly includes the new arguments and evidence submitted by the defendant, which Apple considers inadmissible.

An exchange in favor of the expert opinions

I believe Apple's motion is a deliberate trade-off. On the one hand, there are five expert opinions totaling 126 pages, submitted by Apple in its response; on the other, eight paragraphs from Liu. If the court admits both, Apple loses little and retains the basis on which it ultimately founded its motion.

Apple does not accept Liu's statements: The written submission calls them excuses for the deleted iMac. Apple denies them but leaves them in the file instead of demanding their removal. The hearing before the court in San Jose begins on October 14 at 9 a.m. local time, which is 6 p.m. German time.

Do you think it's wise for Apple to forgo having Liu's statement removed in order to protect its own expert opinions? Let us know in the comments how you think the hearing on October 14th will turn out.

Was this article helpful?
YesNo
Tags: OpenAITechPatient
SendShareSend
Share

Our Amazon Storefront

A handpicked selection of products for iPhone, Mac and more – sorted by topic and updated regularly.

Shop Now

This post contains affiliate links (including Amazon). We earn a small commission on qualifying purchases – at no extra cost to you. Learn more on our Partner Program page.

Previous Post

Apple: Second product rollout expected at the end of October

Next Post

iPhone Duo: App Store now accepts customized apps

Milan Jovicic

Milan Jovicic

Milan founded Apfelpatient in 2016 and has been responsible for all editorial content since 2018 – news, rumors, how-to guides and product reviews. Here, Apple devices aren't review units kept for two weeks, they're everyday tools: from iPhone to MacBook Pro, MacBook Air and iMac all the way to Apple Vision Pro, at least one device from every product category is in daily use, many of them replaced every year. Every menu path in a guide is checked on the device before it goes live.

Related posts

Presumed Innocent: Season 2 Arrives on February 19

by Milan Jovicic
November 20, 2026 - 17:39 CET
Presumed Innocent season 2: Rachel Brosnahan as defense attorney Lelia Reynolds in the courtroom

Presumed Innocent season 2 premieres February 19 on Apple TV, with Rachel Brosnahan and Matthew Rhys as a married couple in a murder trial.

Read moreDetails

Apple is working on an AI agent for apps, browsers, and code

by Milan Jovicic
November 20, 2026 - 01:18 CET
Apple AI agent: Siri AI icon with a shimmering sphere on a white tile against a dark gray gradient

Apple is working on an AI agent that will work with apps, browsers, and code. This is revealed in a job posting that also mentions on-device models.

Read moreDetails

Apple vs. Epic: Apple says Epic's search terms are too broad

by Milan Jovicic
November 19, 2026 - 10:13 PM CET
Apple vs. Epic: illustrated file folder showing case number 4:20-cv-05640 of the commission proceedings on a dark blue background

Apple vs. Epic: Apple says Epic's search terms are too broad and offers a sample to the court instead of all 122,000 documents.

Read moreDetails

Amazon Black Friday Week: The deals for Apple users

by Milan Jovicic
November 19, 2026 - 17:16 CET
Amazon Black Friday week: iPhone Duo showing the words Black Friday Deals on its display

Amazon Black Friday Week until November 30th: The offers for Apple users and which of these prices are genuine Black Friday deals.

Read moreDetails

iCloud backdoor: Court confirms British order

by Milan Jovicic
November 19, 2026 - 3:59 PM CET
iCloud backdoor: Unfolded iPhone Duo in a folio case showing the Advanced Data Protection settings page with the feature turned on

A British court overturns the secrecy: The order to Apple exists, the lawsuit against the iCloud backdoor becomes public.

Read moreDetails
Load More

Categories

  • Apple Insights
  • Apple Rumors
  • Apple News
  • Apple Tips & Tricks
  • iPhone news, rumors and tips
  • Mac and MacBook News
  • Reviews
Make Apfelpatient a preferred source One click – and you'll see us more often on Google

About APFELPATIENT

APFELPATIENT brings you the latest Apple news, product updates, guides, reviews and tips across the entire Apple ecosystem — from the iPhone to the Mac to the Apple Vision Pro. From the first rumors to confirmed news: researched responsibly.

Follow Apfelpatient

Facebook Instagram YouTube Threads Threads

Company

  • About Apfelpatient
  • Contact
  • Author Profiles

Community

  • Netiquette
  • Push notifications
  • RSS feed

Legal

  • Legal Notice
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie settings
  • Affiliate Program

Resources

  • Sitemap

© 2026 Apfelpatient. All rights reserved.

No result
View All Results
  • Home
  • News
  • Rumors
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Reviews
  • Insights

© 2026 Apfelpatient. All rights reserved. Site map

Change language to Deutsch