For many, iCloud is an integral part of everyday digital life. Photos, messages, notes, backups—everything is automatically backed up and encrypted. The promise: a high level of data protection, thanks in part to features like "Advanced Data Protection." But this security promise is currently under political pressure. Great Britain, a democratic constitutional state, wants to force Apple to build backdoors into its encryption—and not just for users in the United Kingdom.
New documents from an ongoing court case in the UK show that the Home Office has demanded more from Apple than previously disclosed. This involves not just access to additional security features, but far-reaching technical measures that would allow global access to iCloud data. The debate about government control versus data protection thus takes on a new dimension.
British government wants access to iCloud worldwide
The Financial Times reports, citing court documents from the British Investigatory Powers Tribunal (IPC), that the Home Office sent Apple a Technical Capability Notice (TCN). This order apparently went significantly further than previously made public. The aim was to oblige Apple to provide and permanently maintain options for data disclosure – not just for British users, but worldwide. The TCN explicitly affected more than just the controversial "Advanced Data Protection" (ADP) feature. Standard iCloud functions were also said to be affected. These include, for example, secured messages, passwords, and entire device backups. The wording in the court documents is clear: the required measures should apply globally – to all user categories and data stored in iCloud, regardless of the user's location or nationality.
Advanced Data Protection under attack
At the end of 2022, Apple introduced ADP, a feature that additionally protects selected iCloud data with end-to-end encryption. This includes photos, notes, iCloud backups, and voice memos. While iCloud data is encrypted in transit and at rest by default, Apple could decrypt it upon legal request – ADP, however, rules this out. After receiving the secret British government order, Apple withdrew the ADP feature for users in the United Kingdom in February 2025. This step received little public comment. Only the new court documents have revealed the extent of the political pressure behind the scenes – and that this withdrawal apparently represents only a partial aspect of the comprehensive demands.
A global case with geopolitical repercussions
What's particularly explosive is that the British demand isn't solely aimed at national security or local law enforcement. Instead, Apple was supposed to provide an infrastructure that would allow access to iCloud data worldwide—even if there's no direct connection to the United Kingdom. Last week, the US reported that Britain had relented and dropped the demands after pressure from US officials—including Director of National Security Tulsi Gabbard and Vice President JD Vance. The court documents now published contradict this account. According to them, the British Home Office has neither lifted nor officially changed its demands.
Apple sticks to its line
Apple continues to take a clear stance against backdoors in its encryption systems. The company regularly warns that any weakening of security ultimately harms all users. A targeted loophole intended for law enforcement or national security services can never be completely secure. Sooner or later, it will also be exploited by criminal groups – a risk Apple is unwilling to take. The ongoing case before the Investigatory Powers Tribunal will be heard publicly early next year. The British government continues to refuse to confirm or deny the order in question, citing obligations of confidentiality. The court has therefore decided to proceed on the basis of "presumed facts" to avoid potential violations of the State Secrets Act.
- iCloud Private Relay: Simple data protection for Safari
- Encrypt iCloud backups: How to do it step by step
Apple versus the state: The dispute over digital sovereignty
The case between Apple and the British government could reignite the debate about data protection, cloud services, and state surveillance. iCloud is at the center of a global conflict of interest: on the one hand, the need for privacy and digital security, and on the other, the demand for control and access to encrypted data. The next few months are likely to be crucial – not just for Apple, but for all services that promise security through encryption. (Image: Shutterstock / BeeBright)
- Apple warns of delays due to new CMA rules in UK
- PayPal data theft: Millions of login details on the darknet
- Germany: Apple is not allowed to call Apple Watch climate neutral
- Elon Musk sues Apple and OpenAI: Dispute over the App Store
