This article may contain affiliate links. Learn more on our Partner Program page.
With more than 122,000 withheld documents, plus a daily fine: With this request, Epic sought to force Apple to release all its files. Now Apple has responded, turning the tables. They claim it wasn't Apple that failed to provide enough information, but rather that Epic's search terms were so broad that they yielded almost exclusively irrelevant results.
On November 18, Apple filed its response to Epic's motion to enforce the disclosure order (Dct. 1731, Case No. 4:20-cv-05640) in Oakland District Court. Epic had requested a daily penalty payment for withheld documents on November 13. The motion requires Apple to release all non-privileged search results by December 2 without first determining their relevance.
Magistrate Judge Thomas S. Hixson is now responsible for the case. Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers assigned it to him on November 17, the same day Hixson granted Epic's request for expedited deadlines (Dct. 1729). The case concerns the documents Apple must submit to justify its proposal for a new commission of up to 15 percent on purchases made through external links in the US App Store.
Key Takeaways
- Apple considers Epic's application legally and factually unfounded and intends to have it dismissed.
- Of the 122,884 documents from the first seven custodians, at least 95 percent would have responded to generic terms such as „fee*“ or „commission*“.
- Releasing all hits by December 2nd is impossible and would disclose sensitive private and business data.
- As a fallback option, Apple, not Epic, is offering to submit a random sample of the withheld documents to a special representative of the court.
- The hearing will take place on November 24th at 7 pm German time via video conference.
Apple's calculation: 95 percent rejects
Epic had calculated that Apple released only 632 documents from the mailboxes of the first seven custodians and withheld more than 122,000. Apple doesn't dispute the order of magnitude but interprets it differently. Apple puts the total number of documents from these seven mailboxes at 122,884. At least 95 percent of these, they claim, triggered general search terms and did not contain the term „link-out“ or variations thereof.
Apple cites wildcard terms like „fee*“, „rate*“, and „commission*“ as examples from the agreed-upon search terms proposed by Epic. These terms encompass not only fees and commissions, but also English words like „feed“ and „feet,“ or the title of the US Football League commissioner. The low number of relevant documents is attributed to these terms, not to any flawed review process.
| Key figure | Value according to Apple's response |
|---|---|
| Documents of the first seven custodians | 122.884 |
| Of these, hits for general terms, without „link-out“ | at least 95 percent |
| Previous testing hours of the service provider | 20.485 |
| Additional testing hours for Epic's request | over 17,000 |
| Custodians in total | 27 |
Apple's arguments against Epic's demand
Apple places the core of its response at the beginning:
The Motion is legally and factually baseless and should be denied.
Only relevant documents should be released, not every search result. According to the response, if Apple were to hand over all results, private tax, financial, and health documents, including those of top managers, documents relating to unannounced products, passwords, and legally protected communications would also end up in Epic's hands. There is not enough time until December 2nd for a renewed review for attorney-client privilege, trade secrets, and personal data, including the necessary redactions.
Apple sees no grounds for a penalty: Nothing indicates that the company is not complying with the order to the best of its ability. Furthermore, Epic did not sufficiently coordinate with Apple before filing the application, as required by the court's procedural rules. Apple summarizes:
Epic has not shown, and cannot show, why the regular discovery process should be disrupted here.
In the event that the court nevertheless rules in favor of Epic, Apple proposes an alternative approach. By December 2nd, a randomly selected, statistically significant sample of the documents deemed irrelevant should be sent to a special representative of the court for review.
The timetable until the hearing
Hixson granted Epic's request for shortened deadlines. Apple had until November 18th to respond, while Epic has until November 20th to reply. The hearing is scheduled for November 24th at 10:00 AM local time (7:00 PM German time) and will take place via Zoom, not in the courtroom as originally planned.
Apple says it intends to substantially complete the release of documents for the remaining 20 custodians by November 25th. The company had already provided substantial documentation for the first seven by November 1st. The deadline for Epic to respond to Apple's commission proposal only begins once the release is complete.
Why sampling is the real way out
I believe Apple's fallback position is the part of its response that will likely prevail in the end. Both sides have a point: search terms that hit „feet“ do indeed produce rejected results, and a ratio of 632 to over 122,000 still requires explanation given the history of excessive claims of privilege. A random sample taken by a special representative answers precisely the question that neither of the two written submissions can resolve: whether Apple's relevance check was sound.
I expect that on November 24th, Hixson will order such an investigation rather than the complete release of all hits. The court has already worked with special representatives in the dispute over Apple's privileged claims. For users in this country, nothing changes as a result of the dispute; it only affects the US App Store. All articles about Apple's store are compiled on the App Store topic page .
Should the court completely relieve Apple of the responsibility for deciding the relevance of its own documents, or would a random check by an independent auditor suffice? Let us know in the comments who you trust more in this matter.





