This article may contain affiliate links. Learn more on our Partner Program page.
Apple has released 632 documents, but is withholding more than 122,000. Epic Games is no longer willing to accept this and is demanding a daily penalty until the documents regarding the planned US commission are fully available. The dispute over Apple's new fees for external payment links has thus shifted once again to the question of what Apple is actually required to disclose.
At the heart of the matter is Apple's proposal from August to reinstate a commission on purchases made through external links in the US App Store. Apple had suggested rates between 5 and 15 percent, as can be seen from the draft of the new App Store commission in the US. Before Epic is required to respond, Apple is to release the documents that explain how these rates were determined.
This is precisely what has fueled the conflict for weeks. Back in October, both sides were already arguing about the scope of the documents related to the US commission. On November 13, Epic filed a motion with the Oakland District Court to enforce the production order (Dct. 1727, Case No. 4:20-cv-05640). Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers is presiding over the case.
Key Takeaways
- Apple released 632 documents from the files of its first seven custodians and retained more than 122,000 as irrelevant.
- Epic puts the percentage of direct search results that are withheld at 99.14 percent.
- Epic is requesting that Apple release all non-privileged hits by December 2nd without its own relevance check.
- A penalty will be due for each day after December 2nd, but Epic does not specify the amount.
- Meanwhile, the dispute over the contempt of court is before the Supreme Court; the oral hearing is scheduled for January 11.
632 against 122,000
The basis for this is an order dated May 20, to which both parties agreed. It obligates Apple to release all non-privileged documents relating to the decision-making process behind the commission proposal, as well as a list of documents that Apple is withholding, citing attorney-client privilege. The search is being conducted using agreed-upon keywords in the files of 27 custodians—that is, individuals whose emails and documents are being examined.
The first seven include Tim Cook, Eddy Cue, Carson Oliver, CFO Kevan Parekh, Nate Barton, Alex Roman, and Phil Schiller. Apple itself identifies the first four as the decision-makers behind the proposal. According to Epic, a total of 157 documents originate from their files.
Apple released 632 documents, including attachments, from all seven mailboxes combined. The company withheld more than 122,000, stating they were not relevant to the proposal. For every document released, more than 190 were withheld.
| Reference value | Value according to Epic's application |
|---|---|
| Published from the first seven Custodians | 632 documents including attachments |
| Withheld as irrelevant | over 122,000 documents including attachments |
| Withheld percentage of direct search results | 99.14 percent |
| Documents from the files of the four decision-makers | 157 |
| Custodians in total | 27 |
From attorney-client privilege to relevance
Epic sees this as a familiar pattern in a new form. In the contempt of court proceedings, Apple withheld tens of thousands of documents as confidential, citing attorney-client privilege. Following a court-supervised review, Apple withdrew 42.1 percent of these claims, according to Epic. Now, the justification is no longer confidentiality, but rather a lack of relevance.
Epic summarizes the accusation as follows:
Apple is withholding well over 99% of the documents returned by running the agreed-to search terms
According to Epic, entire categories are missing: emails regarding the proposed sentences, meeting minutes, internal financial analyses, App Store profit and loss statements, and evidence for Apple's claim that additional costs from external links are practically zero.
What Epic is applying for
Epic wants to take over the relevance check from Apple. Apple is to release all non-privileged documents matching any of the agreed-upon search terms by December 2nd, without having to decide on their relevance beforehand. Apple may continue to check for attorney-client privilege. Epic will determine what is relevant itself.
Apple cannot be trusted to fix this problem on its own
For each day after December 2nd that Apple fails to comply with the order, the court is to impose a daily penalty. Epic has not proposed a specific amount. Apple had announced that it would substantially complete the release of the data from the remaining 20 custodians by November 25th.
Why the document dispute will decide the commission
I consider this motion to be more than just a bureaucratic exercise. The deadline for Epic to respond to Apple's commission proposal only begins once Apple has finalized its decision. As long as this dispute continues, the decision regarding the future fee remains stalled. Until then, the current injunction prohibits Apple from charging any commission on purchases made through external links in the US.
For Apple, time is of the essence. On January 11, the Supreme Court will hear arguments regarding contempt of court, upon which the entire commission case is based. Epic filed its brief challenging Apple's legal standard in mid-November. I expect Justice Gonzalez Rogers will not leave the question of relevance solely to Apple. In April 2025, she found Apple guilty of willful contempt of her ruling and deemed the excessive claims for privilege an attempt to obscure the true decision-making process.
Nothing changes in this country as a result of the dispute. The order and the proposed commission apply exclusively to the US App Store; separate terms and conditions apply to the App Store in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland.
Do you think a commission of 5 to 15 percent on external purchases is fair, or should Apple get nothing at all for external links? Let us know in the comments where you would draw the line.





