Apfelpatient
  • Home
  • News
  • Rumors
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Reviews
  • Insights
No result
View All Results
  • iPhone 18
  • iPhone 18 Pro
  • iPhone Duo
  • Apple Home
  • Siri AI
  • HomePod
  • HomePod mini
  • HomePod mini 2
  • MacBook Pro
  • Apple TV 4K
  • Apple Watch Series 12
  • Apple Watch Ultra 4
  • AirPods 5
  • iOS 27
  • iPadOS 27
  • macOS
  • MacBook Neo
  • iPhone 17e
  • AirTags
  • iOS 26
  • iPhone 17
  • iPadOS
  • iMac
  • Mac mini
  • Apple TV
  • iPad Pro
  • iPhone Air
  • Apple Vision Pro
  • iPhone 16
  • AirPods 4
  • Apple Watch Ultra
  • MacBook Air
  • iPad
  • AirPods Max
  • AirPods Pro 3
  • Mac Studio
  • Studio Display
  • iPad Air
  • iPad mini
  • watchOS 27
  • Apple CarPlay
  • Apple Pay
  • watchOS 26
  • Home
  • News
  • Rumors
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Reviews
  • Insights
No result
View All Results
Apfelpatient
No result
View All Results
  • iPhone 18
  • iPhone 18 Pro
  • iPhone Duo
  • Apple Home
  • Siri AI
  • HomePod
  • HomePod mini
  • HomePod mini 2
  • MacBook Pro
  • Apple TV 4K
  • Apple Watch Series 12
  • Apple Watch Ultra 4
  • AirPods 5
  • iOS 27
  • iPadOS 27
  • macOS
  • MacBook Neo
  • iPhone 17e
  • AirTags
  • iOS 26
  • iPhone 17
  • iPadOS
  • iMac
  • Mac mini
  • Apple TV
  • iPad Pro
  • iPhone Air
  • Apple Vision Pro
  • iPhone 16
  • AirPods 4
  • Apple Watch Ultra
  • MacBook Air
  • iPad
  • AirPods Max
  • AirPods Pro 3
  • Mac Studio
  • Studio Display
  • iPad Air
  • iPad mini
  • watchOS 27
  • Apple CarPlay
  • Apple Pay
  • watchOS 26

Apple counters in DOJ proceedings: Application is baseless

Milan Jovicic by Milan Jovicic
August 18, 2026 - 1:34 PM CEST
in Apple News
0
The curved glass facade of Apple Park in Cupertino, where Apple is conducting its defense in the DOJ proceedings.

Image: Apple

WhatsAppFacebookEmail
Threads

This article may contain affiliate links. Learn more on our Partner Program page.

Make Apfelpatient a preferred source One click – and you'll see us more often on Google

The US Department of Justice wants to retroactively overturn Apple's access to files from 14 federal agencies. Apple's response has now been released – and it dismantles the justification point by point. Particularly embarrassing for the government: Two agencies didn't even explain why the matter would be too time-consuming for them.

The dispute over evidence in the US government's antitrust case against Apple has entered its next phase. In July, Apple won the right to request documents from 14 federal agencies, including the CIA, FBI, NSA, and the Department of Defense. At the end of July, the Justice Department requested that this decision be reconsidered. The response is now contained in document Dkt. 493 in case 2:24-cv-04055, filed on August 13 by Apple's attorney, Liza M. Walsh (via 9to5mac).

Key Takeaways

  • Apple requests that the Justice Department's request be dismissed entirely – it fails on all levels.
  • The 13 subsequently submitted official statements do not constitute new evidence: they could have been submitted 13 months ago.
  • The Department of Commerce and the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) did not submit any statement at all.
  • Several authorities cite expenditure figures without search parameters – the Foreign Ministry, for example, cites over 37,000 hours.
  • A further round of written submissions is out of the question; the decision now rests with the special representative.

What the dispute is about

The Justice Department sued Apple in March 2024 for allegedly anti-competitive practices surrounding the iPhone. Apple's defense is that the challenged design choices are based on objective criteria – security and privacy.

That's precisely why the company wants the government documents. If it can be shown that US federal agencies procured iPhones specifically because of these features, it supports the argument that the stated reasoning is not a pretext. Apple brought this dispute before the relevant judge in May.

In this procedure, such detailed questions are not decided by the main judge, but by a specially appointed representative for the taking of evidence – in this case, the retired federal judge Jose Linares.

The figures that are missing from the explanations

The most interesting part of the document concerns the 13 explanations the government uses to justify the effort. Apple lists what it contains – and what it doesn't.

AuthorityStated effort
Foreign MinistryOver 37,000 hours, without specifying search parameters
NASA194,000 email results from "example" searches, without search terms or mailboxes.
Household office OMBMore than 24 million results from unspecified search terms
NSA„Enormous working hours”, no number
National Intelligence Directorate„considerable working hours”, no number
Department of Homeland SecurityI cannot currently estimate the effort required.

Without knowing the scope and methodology of the search, the claimed effort cannot be assessed, Apple argues. Furthermore, there is a point that contradicts their own explanations: According to their own statements, the FBI and CIA maintain dedicated teams for evidence gathering and regularly provide documents in legal proceedings.

Apple interprets the fact that the Department of Commerce and the FTC did not submit any statement as a tacit admission of guilt – it cannot even be argued that an unreasonable burden would be placed on these two authorities.

Why timing matters

The formal core of the reply is a procedural argument. A motion for reconsideration is an extraordinary measure under US law and requires one of three things: an interim change in the law, new and previously unavailable evidence, or a manifest error of law.

Apple counters that none of these cases apply. The government could have submitted the declarations at any time during the past 13 months since the requests were served. Those who strategically decide against it cannot later rectify this through a request for reconsideration.

The original ruling had already criticized the government for precisely this: its presentation contained no information whatsoever on how many documents would need to be reviewed, how many working hours would be required, or what costs would be incurred.

The dispute over national security

The fact that three intelligence agencies – the CIA, the NSA, and the Office of the Directorate of National Intelligence – were involved raised the question of whether confidentiality interests precluded the release of the documents. The ruling denied this with a clear explanation: National security was not affected simply because Apple had contacted certain agencies.

Apple reiterates that it will not request any classified information. The government can still cite reasons for secrecy regarding individual documents and have material classified as confidential.

The same defense line, two continents

The argument Apple is using in court is the same one that has shaped its dispute with Brussels: design decisions on the iPhone are not anti-competitive, but rather an expression of security and data protection requirements. Apple uses this argument in the EU to justify why Siri AI is not yet launching on iPhones and iPads – see the overview of the DMA dispute for details.

For you as a user in Germany, Austria, and Switzerland, the proceedings have no direct impact – they concern US law and the US market. The interesting aspect lies in the indirect side: Should Apple be able to demonstrate with the regulatory documents that security requirements actually drive product design, this would be an argument that would also resurface in European proceedings. We expect that Apple is retaining this evidence precisely for this purpose.

How the proceedings continue

According to the schedule set on August 4, no further written submissions are permitted. The special envoy will now decide whether to uphold his decision or review it at the government's request. The Justice Ministry's previous request reopened the dispute at the end of July.

Do you think it's appropriate for a company to be allowed to request files from intelligence agencies in antitrust proceedings – or does this evidence gathering go too far? Feel free to disagree in the comments.

  • AirPods with camera: Apple's own code shows the demo video
  • iOS 26.6.1 closes 29 security vulnerabilities on iPhone and iPad
  • iOS 26.6.1 is here: Apple makes the final release
Was this article helpful?
YesNo
Tags: TechPatient
SendShareSend
Share

Our Amazon Storefront

A handpicked selection of products for iPhone, Mac and more – sorted by topic and updated regularly.

Shop Now

This post contains affiliate links (including Amazon). We earn a small commission on qualifying purchases – at no extra cost to you. Learn more on our Partner Program page.

Previous Post

iPhone 18 Pro Max: Variable aperture is said to be exclusive

Next Post

AirPods 5: Code names appear in macOS update

Milan Jovicic

Milan Jovicic

Milan founded Apfelpatient in 2016 and has been responsible for all editorial content since 2018 – news, rumors, how-to guides and product reviews. Here, Apple devices aren't review units kept for two weeks, they're everyday tools: from iPhone to MacBook Pro, MacBook Air and iMac all the way to Apple Vision Pro, at least one device from every product category is in daily use, many of them replaced every year. Every menu path in a guide is checked on the device before it goes live.

Related posts

App Store Awards 2026: These are the 45 finalists

by Milan Jovicic
November 18, 2026 - 3:50 PM CET
App Store Awards 2026: App Store icon hovers above a blue podium

Apple has announced the 45 finalists for the 2026 App Store Awards. Three titles from Germany are among them: Things 3, Ulysses, and Tiny Bookshop.

Read moreDetails

HomeView teardown: Adhesive makes repair risky

by Milan Jovicic
November 18, 2026 - 00:51 CET
HomeView teardown: five tabletop Apple HomeView units side by side showing a clock, a FaceTime call, a photo view, smart home controls and music playback

The teardown reveals that in Apple HomeView, the display, speaker and logic board are glued so tightly that components break during removal.

Read moreDetails

iPhone: Market share expected to rise to 26 percent by 2027

by Milan Jovicic
November 18, 2026 - 00:37 CET
iPhone market share: boxes of the iPhone Duo and two iPhone 18 Pro series models in red and black side by side on a gray surface

Morgan Stanley expects around 270 million iPhones to be sold by 2027, representing a 26 percent market share. Germany lags far behind in the iPhone Duo market.

Read moreDetails

Apple vs. Epic: Epic demands fine over documents

by Milan Jovicic
November 18, 2026 - 00:23 CET
Symbolic image for Apple vs. Epic: illustrated file folder showing the case number of the commission proceedings on a dark blue background

Epic Games is demanding a daily penalty: Apple is withholding over 122,000 documents regarding the planned US commission; only 632 are available.

Read moreDetails

iPhone Duo: Apple now sells replacement parts for self-repair

by Milan Jovicic
November 17, 2026 - 17:09 CET
Folded iPhone Duo in a dark blue case, for which Apple now sells self service repair parts

Repair your iPhone Duo yourself: Apple now sells original parts, also in Germany. The inner display is available separately for €578.99.

Read moreDetails
Load More

Categories

  • Apple Insights
  • Apple Rumors
  • Apple News
  • Apple Tips & Tricks
  • iPhone news, rumors and tips
  • Mac and MacBook News
  • Reviews
Make Apfelpatient a preferred source One click – and you'll see us more often on Google

About APFELPATIENT

APFELPATIENT brings you the latest Apple news, product updates, guides, reviews and tips across the entire Apple ecosystem — from the iPhone to the Mac to the Apple Vision Pro. From the first rumors to confirmed news: researched responsibly.

Follow Apfelpatient

Facebook Instagram YouTube Threads Threads

Company

  • About Apfelpatient
  • Contact
  • Author Profiles

Community

  • Netiquette
  • Push notifications
  • RSS feed

Legal

  • Legal Notice
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie settings
  • Affiliate Program

Resources

  • Sitemap

© 2026 Apfelpatient. All rights reserved.

No result
View All Results
  • Home
  • News
  • Rumors
  • Tips & Tricks
  • Reviews
  • Insights

© 2026 Apfelpatient. All rights reserved. Site map

Change language to Deutsch